Scott Carson of An Examined Life has posted a response to my three replies (beginning here). It appears in one case that I am the party guilty of careless reading. Mea culpa. In any case, his is a thoughtful post, making a nice change of pace from the bulk of the ID "debate." He brings out some important subtleties. I recommend the post and his blog.
For my part, I am still not sure whether I agree with him, but having just eaten and wanting to avoid a sideache, I'm going to wait before I jump back into the ID debate pool. I will probably noodle on this a little before I close out this part of the discussion.