ERICK ERICKSON - We are three days removed from a brutal election for the GOP. A lot has been said.
I have decided it is virtually all bull crap.
Whenever the GOP loses — actually going back to some time around 1972 and the re-election of Richard Nixon — Democrats have told the GOP they are going to lose the demographic battle. Demography is only destiny when you party is obsessed with race as the Democrats are.
Let me explain my thinking with a story from the Old Testament people tend to ignore and work my way up to Dick Cheney. Seriously.
In the Old Testament, Moses had an apprentice named Joshua. Chosen by God to be Moses’s right hand, Joshua took over from Moses. When Joshua died, the wheels came off. Don’t believe me? Flip your Bible to Judges 2:7. Joshua died and all the elders who had surrounded Joshua died. Within five verses we are to “And the people of Israel did what was evil in the sight of the Lord and served the Baals.”
Five verses later!!
No, Baal has nothing to do with Dick Cheney. continue reading...
Showing posts with label 2012. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2012. Show all posts
Friday, November 09, 2012
So Now That We're Here, Where Are We?
In the end, the Republican Party (as the bearer of today's political conservatism) is basically where I thought it was five years ago (pre-Tea Party, pre-Obama), struggling with a bit of an identity crisis, as parties occasionally do. So what's next for the party? Do a reality check, of course, and that means ignoring most of what's being said this week.
Thursday, November 08, 2012
Local Spritual Director for Catholics Against Chastity is At It
Again. This time in a letter to the StarTribune:
Six and half years ago popular orthodox priest and once Relevant Radio darling, Fr. Robert Altier, found himself ordered to focus on his charism (effectively banning him from the radio) and then reassigned as a nursing home chaplain by Archbishop Harry Flynn after stirring the pot regarding the archdiocese's implementation of the safety program in response to the priest sex abuse scandal. In that context, that Fr. Tegeder is still doing parish work is pretty indicative of magnanimity on the part of Archbishop Nienstedt.As a priest of the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis, I would ask our archbishop, John Nienstedt, to prayerfully consider stepping down from his office. It would be healing for our state and our church and would show some magnanimity on his part. His misguided crusade to change our Constitution, spending more than a million dollars and, more importantly, much goodwill, has been rejected. Elections have consequences.
Image: Mark Kartarik, City Pages
THE REV. MICHAEL TEGEDER, Minneapolis
Wednesday, November 07, 2012
Learning Election Lessons
![]() |
| Image: dfb |
The early steam is that Mitt Romney failed to connect with Latinos. Given how vacuous this election was regarding issues and policy, I am not buying the conventional wisdom that it has much to do with immigration directly--don't forget President Obama's epic failure to deliver immigration reform in his first term and how little play he gave it as a policy goal for his second term.
*** Sidebar
Anybody else notice how we had to pass Obamacare so we could learn what was in it, and now we've had to re-elect the president to learn what his agenda for a second term is?
*** End Sidebar
In early 2005, Democracy Corps (Carville, Greenberg, and Shrum) issued an analysis regarding how Democrats could win back white Catholic voters that had voted previously for Bill Clinton, but turned away in increasing numbers from Al Gore and John Kerry. The short of it (not summarized quite like this) was:
Target heterodox Catholics (those who do not meet their Sunday obligation, or who are open to straying from Church teaching regarding pelvic issues, for example) by watering down the heterodoxy and wrapping it in the broader populist language of solidarity, thereby creating an opportunity for those who are happy to rationalize to make themselves feel good about themselves to employ a moral calculus as justification.Here are a couple examples from the report of how a Democrat candidate seeking the white Catholic vote could position himself as someone who:
- Wants to repeal President Bush's tax cut for those earning over two hundred thousand dollars a year, in order to increase funding for health care [read: stem cell research] and education, or
- Is committed to building stronger families by easing the financial burden on parents and promoting prevention [read: contraception] to reduce abortions
Republicans will have to do the same kind of thing with Latinos (and perhaps a percentage of those heterodox non-Hispanic white Catholics), rather than trying to cobble together a cafeteria plate of policy proposals. And they wouldn't have to embrace heterodoxy to do it. The concern is I'm not sure they have it in them.
CREATIVE MINORITY REPORT - This one hurt.
I advised my followers on Twitter last night that the next time I wrote a post about the polls being wrong, somebody should punch me in the ear.
So what does this mean? Many many people, including people smarter than me about these things, expected this to be a turnout election. We expected the turnout to be close to even with either a slight edge to Democrats or a slight edge to Republicans. Either way, most were in a agreement that it wouldn't be anything like 2008. We were wrong. Exit polls have it pegged at D+6, fairly close to 2008.
So, what does this mean. It means that Republicans can no longer win national elections by turning out the base alone. They have to start convincing more people that they have the answers. They can no longer continue to write off blacks and Latinos as un-winnable and expect to win. There is just not enough base to do it.
Another lesson is that Catholics just don't care in the slightest about the persecution initiated by this President and about the unborn. Every indication is that Catholics have granted an imprimatur for their own oppression. continue reading...
Labels:
2012,
Catholic,
Cave Reader,
immigration,
Obama,
politics,
pro-life,
Romney
Tuesday, November 06, 2012
It is Time
I have completed my rosary novena of petition (my novena of thanksgiving begins tomorrow). I am on Day 2 of a three-day fast. I have prayed to the Holy Spirit for wisdom and asked for the intercessions of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the angels and saints that God's Grace be conferred upon the State of Minnesota and the United States of America. I have researched all the candidates and issues.
I now set out with clear eyes and a full heart.
May almighty God have mercy on us, forgive us our sins, and lead us to everlasting life.
Mary Immaculate, patroness of the United States, pray for us.
Our Lady of Guadalupe, patroness of all the Americas, pray for us.
St. Thomas More, patron of religious liberty, pray for us.
St. Jude, my patron, pray for us.
God Bless America!
I now set out with clear eyes and a full heart.
May almighty God have mercy on us, forgive us our sins, and lead us to everlasting life.
Mary Immaculate, patroness of the United States, pray for us.
Our Lady of Guadalupe, patroness of all the Americas, pray for us.
St. Thomas More, patron of religious liberty, pray for us.
St. Jude, my patron, pray for us.
God Bless America!
Poll Watching
In the aftermath of the 2000 election, I did a detailed analysis of the Florida recount that was in process and determined that there was an exceedingly high probability that George W. Bush would be declared the victor if Al Gore in fact was allowed a recount in every county he requested.
I sent my analysis to several newspapers and talk show hosts around the nation. It turns out that about a dozen, or so, other people did the same thing and the idea that we (George W. Bush supporters) needn't fear a transparent recount. In the end, my projection absolutely nailed the end result.
If it had been 4 years later, I probably would have started a blog and would be living a different life right now. Well, maybe.
Why do I mention this? I'm a bit of a stats guy with pretty extensive industrial experience, so I do pay attention to things like polling data, and the modeling method I used in 2000 was essentially the same as what Nate Silver uses at FiveThirtyEight . His expected value model methodology for the electoral college is rock solid.
But... and you know there was one... the devil is in the details. The thing I had in 2000, was that there was quite a bit of data showing that manual recount corrections, under/overvotes, "hanging chads," etc. all followed the original distribution, so it was very straightforward to calculate the probability that Al Gore would pick up enough votes to overtake the certified result with Bush in the lead.
As of this writing, the Real Clear Politics national average has the president up by 0.7% and the average of the states would give President Obama 303 electoral votes (with no toss-ups). Nate Silver has the president at 313 electoral votes with >90% chance of winning (this is approaching statistical certainty).
Now with any Monte Carlo-based model, the key is in how representative the data are to the underlying populations. If the state polls are correct, then Mitt Romney has very little chance of winning. If they are not correct... Nate Silver may go the way of John Zogby.
There is and have been a lot of concerns discussed freely about the accuracy of various state polls, most of which are centered on the turn-out assumption by party that I won't rehash here. I do want to touch on a few things that give me pause in the accuracy of the state polls.
Additional Information
On Polling Models, Skewed & Unskewed
Is Nate Silver's Value at Risk?
Update
The thuggery has begun.
Update 2
Well, it's pretty clear the state polls were correct.
I sent my analysis to several newspapers and talk show hosts around the nation. It turns out that about a dozen, or so, other people did the same thing and the idea that we (George W. Bush supporters) needn't fear a transparent recount. In the end, my projection absolutely nailed the end result.
If it had been 4 years later, I probably would have started a blog and would be living a different life right now. Well, maybe.
Why do I mention this? I'm a bit of a stats guy with pretty extensive industrial experience, so I do pay attention to things like polling data, and the modeling method I used in 2000 was essentially the same as what Nate Silver uses at FiveThirtyEight . His expected value model methodology for the electoral college is rock solid.
But... and you know there was one... the devil is in the details. The thing I had in 2000, was that there was quite a bit of data showing that manual recount corrections, under/overvotes, "hanging chads," etc. all followed the original distribution, so it was very straightforward to calculate the probability that Al Gore would pick up enough votes to overtake the certified result with Bush in the lead.
As of this writing, the Real Clear Politics national average has the president up by 0.7% and the average of the states would give President Obama 303 electoral votes (with no toss-ups). Nate Silver has the president at 313 electoral votes with >90% chance of winning (this is approaching statistical certainty).
Now with any Monte Carlo-based model, the key is in how representative the data are to the underlying populations. If the state polls are correct, then Mitt Romney has very little chance of winning. If they are not correct... Nate Silver may go the way of John Zogby.
There is and have been a lot of concerns discussed freely about the accuracy of various state polls, most of which are centered on the turn-out assumption by party that I won't rehash here. I do want to touch on a few things that give me pause in the accuracy of the state polls.
Caution 1. Regarding the sample adjustments that many polls make. It is a common technique to apply corrective factors to the samples in establishing a likely voter turn-out model (here is an example of an analysis done this way regarding Minnesota's Marriage Protection Amendment back in September). The problem with such an approach is that any adjustments applied based on the poll internals, no longer carry the confidence interval of the top line poll question; the error is increased and is dependent upon the sample sizes of the internal categories used for the adjustments. The accuracy is improved, but at the expense of precision, and I have never seen this explicated consistently in published results, particularly at the state level.So what does this mean? I think any Obama victory will be narrower than what's being projected by RCP and FiveThirtyEight, but we'll probably know pretty early (New Hampshire, Virginia, Pennsylvania) whether the state polls are flawed seriously and there was good reason for all that optimism from the new media right the last couple days. It also means that things will be close and all those extra people doing that other "poll watching" will come into play, ready to delegitimize the result regardless who wins. And it also means that there will be thuggery and shenanigans, which, being in a shenanigan-friendly state with the control of both the state house and senate in play, concerns me greatly. It doesn't matter if they cheat if it's not close, but it's going to be close.
Caution 2. There has been a growing problem in polling regarding response rate of telephone polls since the advent of caller ID. I consider this a potential hidden wild card to create the next Literary Digest event, i.e., where many of these polls in swing states would in effect be unscientific.
Caution 3. While probabilistic estimates like FiveThirtyEight's for an Obama victory have risen from the mid 70% range to over 90%, the Intrade odds have only risen from the mid 60% range to just under 70%. This 1:3 movement indicates a damper of doubt for the recent polls.
Caution 4. As a corrollary to the voter turn-out rates (which is still Caution 0), my old blog buddy, David Hartline, has noted in the state of Ohio that while the focus has been on the populations in 2008 and 2010, the polling has effectively ignored the demographic shifts that have occurred as a result of the recession and weak Obama recovery.
Additional Information
On Polling Models, Skewed & Unskewed
Is Nate Silver's Value at Risk?
Update
The thuggery has begun.
Update 2
Well, it's pretty clear the state polls were correct.
Thursday, June 28, 2012
Now That Obamacare is Just a Political Issue UPDATED
Here are three takes that summarize things fairly well.
From CATO@Liberty:
The USCCB sent out this text message as the bishops renew plea to repair Obamacare:
From National Right to Life:
From my congressman, Rep. John Kline:
From Larry Kudlow on the impact to the economy:
From CATO@Liberty:
The Supreme Court ruled that ObamaCare’s individual mandate is not constitutional under the Commerce Power, which was how Congress framed the mandate to avoid a political backlash from calling it a tax. Congress and the president swore up and down that the mandate was not a tax. Yet the Court upheld the mandate as a valid use of that disavowed taxing power. What Congress said the individual mandate is, the Court said is not constitutional. What Congress said the mandate is not, the Court ruled is constitutional. Everybody got that?From Marjorie Dannenfelser of the Susan B. Anthony List:
Where does that leave us?
The Supreme Court just enacted a law that Congress never would have passed.
The Court just told Congress it is okay to lie to the people to avoid political accountability.
“From the outset, Obamacare is fundamentally flawed legislation because it makes American taxpayers complicit in the deaths of countless unborn children,” said SBA List President Marjorie Dannenfelser. “Today’s decision to uphold the individual mandate to force individuals to purchase health care plans that offend their conscience is incredibly disappointing.And, finally, Obamacare has become the largest tax increase in the history of the world (I don't think that's hyperbole). During one of the nation's largest recessions--possibly double-dipping now. If you think that will support the middle class, you are a moron. Literally. From the Greek (not the Joe Biden sense of "literally").
“Over the last four years, President Obama has revealed his loyalty to the abortion industry. At no time was this clearer than during the health care reform debate, when he fought tenaciously for the largest expansion of taxpayer funding of abortion on demand since Roe v. Wade. As the presidential race heats up, the Susan B. Anthony List will continue to remind American voters where the President’s allegiance truly lies. We will not stop fighting until every U.S. taxpayer is freed from under-writing the abortion business.”
Update:
The USCCB sent out this text message as the bishops renew plea to repair Obamacare:
After today's ruling, the contraception mandate still remains. Keep up your prayers and action for religious freedom!
Update 2:
From National Right to Life:
“All voters who care about the value and dignity of human life must do everything they can to elect Mitt Romney and a Congress who are committed to repeal of ObamaCare,” said National Right to Life President Carol Tobias. “If President Obama wins re-election, it will mean massive abortion subsidies and it will put the lives of millions at risk through systematic government-imposed rationing of lifesaving medical care.”
Today’s U.S. Supreme Court ruling upholding most of the ObamaCare law is a call-to-action for the right-to-life electorate to work to elect a Congress and president this November committed to repealing ObamaCare in 2013, in order to prevent a future in which abortion insurance will be heavily subsidized by federal taxpayers and federal bureaucrats will be authorized to ration life-saving medical treatment.
Update 3:
From my congressman, Rep. John Kline:
Update 4:
From Larry Kudlow on the impact to the economy:
Twenty new or higher taxes across-the-board are bad for economic growth, bad for job hiring, bad for investors, and bad for families.
A tax is a tax is a tax, according to Judge Roberts. But he forgot to say that if you tax something more, you get less of it. ...
Obamacare is not just a huge tax hike. It’s also a major new spending entitlement that’s already pegged at $2.5 trillion and will increase the federal debt burden much faster than the GDP expands.
In other words, tax, spend, regulate, borrow. The Obama mantra. ...
Bankrupting the economy is not exactly a job-creator.
Labels:
2012,
health care,
Obama,
policy,
politics,
religious freedom
What This Morning May Bring UPDATED
Update (bumped to top)
Obamacare appears to have been upheld as constitutional in the main. Now it gets interesting... Expect potential nullification challenges from several states (although the limitations on Medicaid expansion may prevent them), and, of course, repeal just joined the economy as a primary issue for the fall. Welcome to a long, hot summer.
Original Post
I am not one for predicting what the Supreme Court will do, but my growing unease since the Arizona decision on Monday is reflected in the Intrade market regarding the question of the individual mandate being declared unconstitutional by it's drop of 10% in the last two days since that decision was announced.
The individual mandate is, of course, at the center of the legal challenge, but it is not all that is wrong with a law that I find to be bad, bad, bad. To review the bidding...
As I noted following the passage of Obamacare:
If I have to buy insurance to drive a car, that's fine. I don't have to drive. I can walk, ride a bike, take the bus, whatever.There's a world of difference in coercing the execution of a private contract simply because you exist vs. usage requirements for public goods/services (driving), or engaging in potentially exploitive (pornography or prostitution), or dangerous behavior (public narcotic use or recklessness). But my objection to this law goes beyond the individual mandate. It violates the principle of subsidiarity at both the state and individual levels. It doesn't provide for conscience protections (or has very limited ones). Its costs have been obfuscated and when fully implemented will be nearly 3x what was advertised at its passing. The promise of my getting to keep my insurance, if I liked it at the time of passage, is patently false. It will create dislocations in reimbursements to service providers, or access to services. In the end, it actually still won't ensure everyone has coverage because of the incentives built in for adverse selection. I could go on.
If I have to pay an airport tax to help defray the costs of the TSA, that's fine, too. I don't have to get on an airplane. I can walk, ride a bike, take the bus, whatever.
This bill says that I have to purchase health insurance. I don't have to drive or fly, but I do have to live.
On a more personal level, my self-insured employer has already started taking compliance steps that have increased my out of pocket costs by thousands of dollars, with less coverage and fewer plan options. I've been able to hold my job (and had to hold my job), so I haven't had to face the issue of pre-existing conditions, deniability for which is a real problem in today's "market." Yes, the current law's guaranteed issue provision works to that situation. However, beyond my incomplete list above, I just don't think such relief will be anything but temporary, i.e., the situation will be unsustainable before I reach retirement age because of costs, or unacceptable because of rationing--I just don't buy it; I don't think it will work and it will cost a lot of people a lot more money. There are alternate remedies that better address the underlying problems.
Regardless any elements of noble intent and desirable features, I think it is a bad law that addresses the wrong problem. The health care problem in need of reform is insufficient (a term I'll stipulate) access to needed and affordable health care services. Congress' remedy here is to coerce the execution of private contracts in a derivative market, namely the health insurance market that serves the health care services market. To what end? To correct problems that Congress itself created through price controls, anti-competitive constraints, and guaranteed service requirements. Yeah, that's not gonna work.To apply general tools to specific problems is to fail.
Solve the problem. And that means starting over.
Labels:
2012,
health care,
policy,
politics,
religious freedom
Wednesday, April 11, 2012
Why I was (am) for Rick
I was chatting with our eldest daughter, Troglotyke #2, on the night of the South Carolina primary when Rick Santorum came on to give his "concession" speech. We continued to chat about who was doing well relative to expectations and the like. Now, we do have those famed family discussions around the kitchen table, and, on occasion, the topic does turn to politics, so there wasn't any question where we stand generally on the political scale/plane, or why. At this point, she begins paying attention to the speech on the TV (beginning around the 9-minute mark in the clip below), and as she listens her eyes widen and a look of recognition comes across her face and she turns to me and says:
Faith. Family. Freedom. Undermine one, undermine all.
We are at a crossroads as a nation. America, and indeed Western Civilization, is faced with the prospect of having to proceed in an era of globalization without the institution of the family and with a shrinking mobility for a middle class.
Rick Santorum understands better than the other candidates the profound link between the moral, cultural, and economic principles that have marked America as an exceptional nation in history. The Dignity of Life and the Dignity of Work go hand in hand with the strength of the family as an institution and the health of the middle class, and both were central to his agenda as president.
On the issues of the day, Rick Santorum has been out front in opposing the overreaches and failures of the Obama administration:
None of the other competitive candidates could claim that entire list.
He has been a passionate, consistent, and articulate advocate for the Culture of Life and has been savaged by the left for upholding and living out traditional family values.
Even at the end of the campaign, I thought Rick Santorum could still best articulate both social and fiscal conservative values, have an agenda that works toward ensuring opportunity and security for all, including the middle class in particular, and have the wherewithal to follow-through and live those values as president.
America is still a great nation and can be greater still, so long as we remain good stewards of Faith, Family, and Freedom. With Rick Santorum, I think we could have had a president who believed this to his core and would have led accordingly.
But it's not to be...
Rick has pledged to do what he can to bring a change about in the White House. However, his campaign has debt, so, if you support that fight, please consider a donation of $10 or $20 or more to free up resources to help defeat Barack Obama in November.
Oh my gosh, Dad. He sounds just like you! That's the way you talk.
SANTORUM: I've talked often in my speeches about the liberal think tank that says that if you do three things that you can almost guarantee to stay out of poverty. Work that I just talked about, get that education, graduate from high school, and, of course, get married before you have children. Marriage, family --I'm not going to pretend I thought Santorum to be my perfect candidate, but what my daughter recognized that night, I had seen months earlier, and why I supported him for president...
If we are not the party that stands up for the truth about the importance of marriage, the importance of families, the importance of fatherhood and motherhood, the importance of those values of instilling virtues in the next generation of children with faith, then we are a party that no longer has a heart. And we are not a party that's going to be a majority party in this country. We have to be the party that speaks to everyone, those who know and understand that at the heart of America, that beating sound is that beating pulse of the healthy family.
Faith. Family. Freedom. Undermine one, undermine all.
We are at a crossroads as a nation. America, and indeed Western Civilization, is faced with the prospect of having to proceed in an era of globalization without the institution of the family and with a shrinking mobility for a middle class.
Rick Santorum understands better than the other candidates the profound link between the moral, cultural, and economic principles that have marked America as an exceptional nation in history. The Dignity of Life and the Dignity of Work go hand in hand with the strength of the family as an institution and the health of the middle class, and both were central to his agenda as president.
On the issues of the day, Rick Santorum has been out front in opposing the overreaches and failures of the Obama administration:
- the bailouts,
- the so-called stimulus,
- the individual health care mandate,
- the HHS mandate,
- exploding deficits as a share of GDP,
- cap-and-trade,
- border security, and
- the naïveté of Obama's charm offensive against those who have sworn to be our enemies, including, in particular, a nuclear-seeking Iran
None of the other competitive candidates could claim that entire list.
He has been a passionate, consistent, and articulate advocate for the Culture of Life and has been savaged by the left for upholding and living out traditional family values.
Even at the end of the campaign, I thought Rick Santorum could still best articulate both social and fiscal conservative values, have an agenda that works toward ensuring opportunity and security for all, including the middle class in particular, and have the wherewithal to follow-through and live those values as president.
America is still a great nation and can be greater still, so long as we remain good stewards of Faith, Family, and Freedom. With Rick Santorum, I think we could have had a president who believed this to his core and would have led accordingly.
But it's not to be...
Rick has pledged to do what he can to bring a change about in the White House. However, his campaign has debt, so, if you support that fight, please consider a donation of $10 or $20 or more to free up resources to help defeat Barack Obama in November.
Labels:
2012,
Obama,
politics,
Santorum,
Speleology (Commentaries)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


